Twice. Yes, she had to make two trips to our house after Tyler lost his first tooth. It sounds like people do some fancy things for the Tooth Fairy, but we just put his tooth in a small glass on the kitchen counter and in the morning, there were 4 quarters in there instead of the tooth. When Tyler saw this, he got a little sad. “But I wanted to keep my tooth,” he said. I mentioned it on Facebook the next day and I got several suggestions about how to handle that situation such as leaving a note asking if she’ll leave the tooth. Since it was too late for that, we told him that he could write another note, and hope that she’d come back and see it. Tyler wrote a very nice note and left it with the 4 quarters—willing to sacrifice his tooth money to get his tooth back.
Wouldn’t you know it, she came back and returned his tooth. Next time we’ll know better, I guess! He did say that he just wanted to show it to Matt, and then the Tooth Fairy can have it back. I don’t think she’s going to want to make another trip though….we’ll see. His next tooth is a little wiggly, so we’ll probably be doing it again soon!